WHAT PPC CAN TELL YOU ABOUT A MARKET

Paul Carpenter 4th July 2007
Paul Carpenter

PPC isn't merely a tool to drive customers to your site. It is also a tool that can help you determine the true value of keywords - and the state of the market as a whole.

In this article, we're taking a close look at just one set of metrics provided by Google AdWords and what lessons you might divine from it. Hopefully, you'll get a little bit of insight into how we arrive at some of the decisions we make when managing a pay per click campaign.

Market Reality vs. Perception

Google's AdWords Keyword tool is quite nifty for keyword research. Whilst it gives away a lot less information than, say, Overture (you won't see the actual number of searches performed on Google anywhere unless you're paying for ads) you can still pick up useful information.

We're currently doing some work for a software developer. One of the things that they have asked we look into is software integration - which is one of the terms they believe describes a lot of what they do.

Google's keyword tool reveals an interesting pattern. The competition for advertising slots around that keyword is very fierce, but the search volumes are actually relatively low.

In the screenshot below, the competition is the column of green bars on the right, whilst the 'search volume' is the column of green bars on the left.

Nice Screenshot. What's it Telling Me?

One thing it isn't telling you is the number of searches, or the number of competitors who are advertising. What is does indicate is that there might be more competition than the phrases themselves warrant. Deciphering that information isn't easy.

Some potential negatives you might take from that information

  • The market is saturated
    It may just reflect the fact that there are a lot of software integration companies out there. Perhaps the barriers to entry in the market are low. If so: can you make money from it or will you always be competing for low-value business in a business where fees are going down rather than up?
  • The term is an 'insiders' term
    In technical markets, companies often make the mistake of assuming that their potential clients speak the same language as themselves. In this case, perhaps 'software integration' is something that immediately leaps into the head of tech companies when you ask what they do. Perhaps that's not even something that potential customers can even imagine. They might be after better sales data from their software, or how to install Outlook Express. Result? Lots of competition for a low value keyword.
  • Clicks might be expensive
    Given the amount of advertiser competition, it seems likely that getting a top 3-5 slot for an ad might be quite pricey. Again, this is subjective, but looking at the context of your overall budget can help you decide whether or not buying traffic at possibly £5 a click is worth it, and whether you can offer something so compelling to turn speculative clicks into concrete enquiries. If the term is pretty vague, then the chances fall. In this case, 'software integration' might mean someone's looking for detailed technical advice - not a sales pitch - in which case your £5 is up in smoke.

Some potential positives you might take from that information

  • There's no smoke without fire
    If lots of people are bidding for a term that has a relatively small search volume, it might suggest that conversions are high value. You might have to buy dozens of low value clicks (speculators) at a cost of hundreds, but a single enquiry might bring about a 6 month, £100,000 project.
  • The leads are self qualifying
    It might be that people who type in these terms are highly qualified just because of the term they use. This is often true in technical markets, where specialist terms reflect specialist knowledge and needs. That normally means you have a strong opportunity to place a highly specific pitch.
  • There might be a gap in the market
    By actually searching on Google for some of the terms in the list will highlight what it is that other people are trying to sell. If other companies are offering broadly comparable services, it's a great chance to differentiate yourself - either on price or service.

So How are we Using This Information?

Ah... that would be telling! But in this case, we'll probably recommend that the company look at more niche terms - referring to specific software products and platforms they can work with. We think that, for what they offer in terms of their product mix, that these kind of terms are probably going to be too broad to fit in with their budget.

As we help them to create a focussed product offering, then this picture might change.

Today's Moral

Advertising online isn't just about buying clicks and watching the numbers. It can be used as part of nuanced market research to help you develop your understanding of a marketplace - particularly where the organic results might be tilted towards noncommercial results.

If you're managing your PPC campaign yourself, or if your website marketing company can't advise you at this sort of level, then it's time to take a long hard look at what you're doing. You don't operate in a vacuum, and having a broader vision of where you sit in the marketplace can be the first step to a much better website performance.

ADD YOUR COMMENT

Are you human? (sorry to ask!)
Please answer this question in the box below:

OTHER ARTICLES


THINK TANK
  • Web Design Yorkshire - Local Maps Fail
    "I think they must have been reading! That spurious result is history as of yesterday...."
    Paul Carpenter
    Why I Don't Rank For Zoe Piper
    "Hi! Zoe's page has always been titled for 'Zoe Piper' (check the Google index for the page) so I'm guessing it must have been a momentary database fail or something when you were looking Atom. I don't think the 'use your name many times in the body' advice is going to cut the mustard though. It used to work once upon a time, but if it were that easy (and I guess you're hinting at keyword density here) then it would be *easy* to rank for anything and we'd all be millionaires :) The thrust of Zoe's point is that www.zoepiper.com is a content free holding page, with no links and essentially of no value for anyone searching for 'Zoe Piper'. Google could show any other result from the first page of the SERPS at the top and it would be more relevant and useful..."
    Paul Carpenter
    How to Reindex Your Website Quickly in a Search Engine
    "same problem i am having with my new site updates at http://www.tmc.edu.sg sheesh .... "
    BBC
    Google and UK Spelling: 'Optimisation' vs 'Optimization'
    "Australia supports your crusade! pufft realizing indeed"
    Ian
    Why I Don't Rank For Zoe Piper
    "Hi Atom, I should really check my meta tags - thought they'd populate by default tbh! It's interesting with something like this to see how different factors are weighted, from URL to internal links to meta tags etc like you say. Unfortunately I can't go overboard on my profile page, it has to be short and sweet so on-page content is pretty much a no-no! Ah well...if people want me they'll find me. Thanks for the comment :)"
    Zoe
    Why I Don't Rank For Zoe Piper
    "Hi Zoe, There are some major reasons your not ranking. Your Meta tags say ""My Default Keywords". Also your name appears once in your profile page and the other time it does it is an image so that doesn't help. I bet if you added your full name to your profile some more times it would put you up in rankings. Also LinkedIn will has your name on one page over 50+ times so you need alot more usage to compete. But that is the way it goes. This is only a profile so I am sure you're limited. Despite having loads of content linked to your profile, Google also wants to see the relevance of Zoe Piper on this page and is only seeing it once. "
    Atom McCree
    Web Design Yorkshire - Local Maps Fail
    "I guess they do have quite a lot of services no-one uses...."
    Zoe
    Web Design Yorkshire - Local Maps Fail
    "Yet another useless, half arsed service from Google. "
    The Floating Frog
    “Cloaking” Content for SEO (Or What Happens When Your SEO Company Isn’t Telling What They’re Up To)
    "I thought these techniques died out with Windows 98', these people need to find a new career. Nice writeup BTW"
    The Floating Frog
    Web Design Yorkshire - Local Maps Fail
    "I've noticed this a lot recently - stupid map results like this that basically hand over a big slice of the search market to one company on the basis of what is (presumably) a bug. Fortunately, long term we're repositioning as a 'digital agency' in Leeds/Yorkshire because our portfolio offering is much wider so who cares ;-)"
    Carps

Get in touch

View our portfolio